Séminaire de Physique Théorique
Canonical transformations, observables, and Mach's principleMikhail Volkov (IDP, Tours)
Thursday 03 December 2026 14:00 - Salle des séminaires - Salle 1180, bâtiment E2
Résumé :
Canonical transformations (CTs) preserve the form of Hamilton equations but change the Hamiltonian. For example, they can map it to zero. Moreover, they can relate to each other {\it any} two systems of same number of degrees of freedom. For example, a stable system can be canonically mapped to an unstable one. This creates a paradoxal impression that CTs change physics. We argue that the paradox arises only if the system with Hamiltonian $H(p,q,t)$ is considered as totally isolated. The resolution is to put it into contact with an external detector measuring the system coordinates $p,q$. The system+detector can be described by ${\cal H}=H(p,q,t)+\lambda qQ+H_{det}(P,Q)$, which determines the detector response $P(t),Q(t)$. Having chosen ${\cal H}$, the coordinates $p,q$ can be canonically transformed, which changes $H(p,q,t)$, but the detector response does not change. Therefore, the observed physics remains CT independent. It follows that a totally isolated system cannot have dynamics, since its Hamiltonian can be canonically transformed to any value. The dynamics emerges via coupling to the outside world represented by the detector/observer. This viewpoint is reminiscent of Mach's principle, according to which dynamics can be defined only in the presence of ``distant stars''. It follows also that classical mechanics, similarly to quantum theory, needs the external observer for its logical consistency.
Liens :
